Achieving Race Balance in the Game of Planets: A Comprehensive Analysis By An A.I.

NOTE: For the fun of it, we’ve brought in a new guest writer this week: ChatGPT! This article was written by a chatbot following several hours of laborious training, and is based entirely on extant game documentation. Readers, how does it compare?


Race balance is a crucial aspect of any strategy game, including the popular game of Planets. In Planets, players can choose from eleven distinct races, each with its own set of advantages and characteristics. Achieving race balance is essential to ensure a fair and engaging gameplay experience for all participants. In this article, we will delve into the race balance in Planets, examining the strengths and weaknesses of each race and exploring the implications for gameplay dynamics.

The Importance of Game Balance:

Game balance is of paramount importance in Planets as it ensures that no single race or strategy dominates the gameplay. It provides players with equal opportunities to succeed, promotes strategic thinking, and encourages diverse gameplay styles. Achieving a well-balanced game environment enhances the overall experience and fosters healthy competition among players.

1.The Eleven Races: Let’s start by briefly introducing the eleven races available in Planets:

1.1. The Colonies: Known for their ability to build fighters and control minefields effectively, the Colonies excel in ship customization and defensive strategies.

1.2. The Rebels: With their unique abilities to colonize Arctic planets and sabotage enemy planets, the Rebels are a versatile and disruptive force.

1.3. The Robots: The Robots possess exceptional mine-laying capabilities and immunity to star cluster radiation, making them formidable opponents in both offense and defense.

1.4. The Empire: The Empire’s strengths lie in their Dark Sense ability, the Super Star Destroyer, free starbase fighters, ship cloning, and powerful Gorbie Class Battlecarriers.

1.5. The Crystals: Crystal race advantages include faster growth on desert planets, web minefields that immobilize enemy ships, and the ability to tow capture ships, making them experts in hindering enemy movements.

1.6. The Cyborgs: The Cyborgs excel at assimilating natives, repairing their ships, recovering resources from defeated enemies, and Firecloud mobility.

1.7. The Privateers: Known for their piracy skills, the Privateers can rob enemy ships of their fuel and cargo, and capture ships without fuel.

1.8. The Fury: The Fury race specializes in ground combat, with superior ground defense and offense ratios, the ability to pillage planets, and immunity against planetary attacks.

1.9. The Birds: Birds are adept at gathering intelligence through spying, cloak and intercept missions, changing enemy planetary friendly codes, and maintaining cloaked ships.

1.10. The Lizards: The Lizards possess remarkable ground combat capabilities, enhanced mining efficiency, survivability in starship battles, and the ability to prevent civil wars through fear.

1.11. The Federation: The Federation excels in taxation, crew bonuses, ship refits, and quantum torpedoes, offering a versatile playstyle.

  1. Analyzing Race Balance: Achieving race balance in Planets is a delicate task, as each race has its unique strengths and weaknesses. Here are some key factors to consider when assessing race balance:

2.1. Specialized Abilities: Races with specialized advantages, such as the Colonies’ ship customization or the Fury’s ground combat prowess, offer unique strategic opportunities. Balancing these advantages with corresponding drawbacks is crucial to avoid overpowered or underwhelming gameplay experiences.

2.2. Versatility: Races that possess a diverse range of abilities, like the Rebels or the Empire, can adapt to various situations, making them formidable opponents. Striking a balance between versatility and specialization is vital for race balance.

2.3. Interaction with Game Mechanics: Some races have advantages that directly interact with game mechanics, such as mine-laying, ship cloning, or spying. Ensuring these interactions are balanced and do not disrupt the game’s core mechanics is essential.

2.4. Late Game Balance: It’s crucial to consider the balance of races in the late game when players have fully developed their empires. Races with early game advantages might need to be balanced against races with stronger late-game potential to maintain a dynamic gameplay experience.

Ranking By Race:

  1. The Cyborgs: With the exceptional mobility of the Firecloud and the power of the Biocide, the Cyborgs remain at the top of the ranking. Their ability to assimilate natives and the advantage of cloning captured ships further solidify their position as a strong race.
  2. The Empire: Despite the lack of diversity in torpedo ships, the Empire’s Gorbie remains an extremely powerful vessel. Their Dark Sense ability and the hyperspace scout contribute to their strategic capabilities.
  3. The Lizards: As a well-rounded race, the Lizards’ strong ground defense and combat ratios, coupled with the Hissss! ability to prevent civil wars, make them a formidable force. Their mining bonus also provides an economic advantage.
  4. The Colonies: The Colonies’ unique advantages of free fuel generation and fighter minesweeping, along with the cost-efficient and combat-ready Virgo ship, make them a strong contender.
  5. The Birds: While economically weak, the Birds excel in stealth and have the advantage of Loki immunity. Their Super Spy Deluxe ability and cloak and intercept mission enhance their espionage capabilities. However, their overall power is limited compared to other races.
  6. The Privateers: The Privateers’ abilities to rob ships and capture vessels through towing are indeed powerful. However, their vulnerability to races with Lokis or Glory Devices, as well as countermeasures like web mines and Robot minefields, diminishes their strength.
  7. The Crystals: With the strategic advantage of web mines and the ability to capture ships through towing, the Crystals are a force to be reckoned with. Their defensive capabilities are particularly notable.
  8. The Fury: While challenging to play, the Fury race compensates with powerful offensive abilities such as pillaging and the use of Glory Devices. Their cloaking ability enhances their strategic maneuverability. However, their weak battleship and light fleet limit their defensive capabilities.
  9. The Robots: The Robots’ high ship costs and lack of significant advantages put them at a disadvantage compared to other races. Their exceptional minelaying ability remains a valuable asset, but overall, they fall behind in terms of power.
  10. The Rebels: The Rebels’ advantages in ground assault and the ability to sabotage planets are strong, but their vulnerability to cloakers and particularly Privateers reduces their overall ranking. Their offensive capabilities outweigh their defensive strength.
  11. The Federation: While well balanced and benefiting from extra tax income and diplomatic advantages, the Federation lacks a standout advantage or exceptionally powerful ships, placing them at the bottom of the ranking.

Here are some speculations as to why the actual game results may differ from the initial assessment:

  1. Empire’s Weakness: The Empire may be perceived as weak due to their limited torpedo ship options, which could affect their combat effectiveness. Additionally, their weakness in minefields and defensive strategies might make them more vulnerable in certain offensive scenarios.
  2. Robots’ Weakness: The Robots’ higher ship costs compared to their capabilities could make them less cost-effective in battles, putting them at a disadvantage against races with more efficient ship designs. Their focus on minelaying may also limit their offensive capabilities, making them weaker in direct confrontations.
  3. Privateers’ Strength: The Privateers’ strength could be attributed to their unique abilities such as Rob Ship and Tow Capture, which provide them with powerful options for resource acquisition and ship control. These abilities can give them an advantage in both economic and tactical aspects of the game.
  4. Federation’s Strength: The Federation’s perceived strength could be due to their well-balanced nature and their economic advantages, such as the 200% Taxing and Super Refit abilities. These advantages allow them to generate higher resource income and upgrade their ships, giving them an edge in both economy and combat.


Game balance is a fundamental aspect of Planets that influences the overall experience for players. The equilibrium between races, strategies, and planetary defenses ensures that no single approach dominates the game. By carefully considering the race-specific strategies, understanding the evolving nature of planetary defenses, and maintaining an open line of communication with the player community, developers can achieve a well-balanced and captivating gameplay environment in Planets.

Generated with the assistance of GPT-3.5, an AI language model developed by OpenAI.

Any Planets Magazine readers who are interested in supporting Gnerphk’s fiction writing can donate directly at Patreon.

As always, you can make a PayPal donation to support the Planets Magazine, or click the button below to Buy Us A Coffee. It’s always a fun boost for our morale. As an added benefit, the more you pay us, the less likely we are to rely on chatbots to produce content in the future. Think of it less as blackmail than commerce in action: You get what you pay for.

Buy Me A Coffee

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s